In the second half of the twentieth century, people’s ideas about sexual relationships began to change and become more liberal. Women could get birth control more easily and some states made it easier to get abortions.
However, these changes also created problems. Some poor women who lived in a state that outlawed abortion could not travel to get treatment. Some people said that this was not fair. Abortion laws were sometimes vague, so that doctors did not know when they were breaking the law. Also, some people said that the government should not tell people what to do in sexual relations. They said this was an invasion of privacy.
The U.S. Constitution does not say clearly that there is a right to privacy. However, the Supreme Court had said in other cases that a person has a right to privacy in particular places, like the home. In the case of Griswold v. Connecticut (1965), the Supreme Court said that Connecticut could not stop married couples from getting birth control. The Court said that families have a right to privacy in their decisions about having children and sexual relationships. The Court said that privacy was a basic value that is important for all the rights in the Bill of Rights.
Jane Roe (not her real name) was unmarried and pregnant and lived in Texas. She wanted to have an abortion, but according to Texas law she could not have an abortion unless her life was in danger. Roe challenged the law by suing Wade, the district attorney where she lived.
Roe argued that she had a right to privacy and should be able to decide whether to have an abortion or not. She argued that the right to privacy comes from combining several other rights listed in the Bill of Rights. The state argued that “the right to life of the unborn child is superior to the right to privacy of the mother.” The state also argued that this is a topic that should be left to the legislatures to decide how to handle. A three-judge federal district court ruled the Texas abortion law unconstitutional. The case was then appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court.
Questions to Consider
What Texas law was Roe challenging?
What were two problems with abortion laws?
Where does the constitution state that you have a right to privacy?
What arguments did each side make?